Neck Pain and Working Around Physical Conditions

Context

Sara (a friend of Patrick’s) and Clementine both raised concerns during Session 5 about neck pain during certain movements, particularly transitions in and out of Reclining Transition and spinal flexion-extension initiated from the head. After the session, Sara expressed some frustration in a hallway conversation, comparing her experience to Pilates with a reformer where she doesn’t experience neck pain. There was mild skepticism and a sense that Patrick wasn’t being empathetic to her situation.

Key Points from Session 5 Discussion

Asia explained that neck tension often originates elsewhere in the body—the abdominal wall, lower back, shoulders, or pelvic floor—due to fascia chains. The approach is to focus on movements that don’t aggravate the condition while continuing to practice, rather than focusing on the pain site directly.

Patrick shared his own experience: “I had neck problems my whole life from doing yoga… I had a herniation in the C6, C7 vertebrae. I was stiff like this for ten years. I fixed it with Baseworks.”

---

Draft Personal Message to Sara

Hi Sara,

I wanted to follow up on our conversation outside after the session today.

First, I want you to know that I absolutely understand how frustrating and uncomfortable working with neck pain can be. It’s real, it’s limiting, and I didn’t mean to come across as dismissive of what you’re experiencing. If it seemed that way, I’m sorry.

The reason I keep emphasizing finding movements that don’t hurt—rather than figuring out how to push through movements that do—comes from my own experience. I’ve worked with countless physiotherapists over the years who gave me useful information, but none of it ever really solved the underlying problems. What actually helped was learning to move more intelligently around whatever obstacle existed, finding ways to coexist with and eventually work through chronic conditions rather than trying to power past them.

I completely understand the comparison to Pilates with a reformer—of course an external apparatus makes certain movements accessible in ways that floor work doesn’t. But part of what we’re trying to develop here is the capacity to find those adaptations internally, without relying on equipment. That takes time, and it’s genuinely a different skill.

Asia’s point about fascia chains is really important here too: neck tension often isn’t actually originating in the neck. It could be the abdominal wall, lower back, shoulder muscles, or even the pelvic floor creating a pattern that manifests as neck discomfort. That’s why we keep encouraging focus on what you can do comfortably rather than troubleshooting the pain site directly.

I also want to say—I’m actually blown away by how well you’re understanding the movements and forms. You’re picking things up quickly, and that’s clear to both Asia and me. We can’t overemphasize how much of a work-in-progress all of this is. Some things take longer to click, and that’s completely normal. We always encourage a more considerate approach around whatever issues come up, just to make the whole thing sustainable.

Hope this lands well. See you Saturday.

Patrick

---

Key Principles Applied

1. Acknowledge the experience: Neck pain is real and limiting—don’t dismiss it
2. Personal experience as context: Patrick’s own history with neck issues and how he resolved them through Baseworks
3. Internal vs. external apparatus: Reformer makes movements accessible externally; Baseworks develops internal adaptive capacity
4. Fascia chains: Neck tension often originates elsewhere in the body
5. Focus on what works: Practice movements that don’t aggravate the condition
6. Affirm progress: Acknowledge what’s going well to balance the challenging conversation

---

---

Sara’s Response

Hey Patrick (and Asia), thanks for your text. You have nothing to apologize for - I didn’t perceive anything you said to be dismissive in the least!

I’m not interested in pushing through movements that hurt (or powering past pain points) either, so we are on the same page. I prefer one-on-one body work in general exactly because of that. I know from past experience that in a group setting I’m likely to unintentionally end up hurting my neck or back. It’s just the nature of the beast. That said, you are very good at spotting people who are having issues and helping with workarounds, which is very helpful 😊.

Indeed, my neck pain comes from multiple causes in different parts of my body. I was actually at physio today and my PT asked me if I tend to breathe through my neck shallowly instead of my diaphragm / ribcage because of specific tension she was noticing. I’d never thought about it before, but I think I might. So, I can add that to my list now 🤣.

I also didn’t intend to compare Baseworks to reformer Pilates, so I apologize for the miscommunication. I was trying to explain how I was feeling about a movement I couldn’t do and it was the only analogy I could think of but I don’t think we quite understood each other. I have never powered through pain using a reformer - it is the opposite, but it’s a rehab device (in addition to being used for general fitness) and that’s the bit I was trying to explain. I was basically trying to explain that with my particular issues sometimes I really just can’t do certain movements with my own body weight (without experiencing a lot of discomfort) even if it seems really basic and not at all difficult to the instructor. I’ve had this problem trying to do beginner yoga, beginner mat pilates, even swimming lessons (where the instructor had us all kicking with a kickboard and that was unbearable for my neck). It just is what it is. Sometimes there is no modification that will work without an assistive device to enable me to go through a much more gentle iteration of the movement, and I need to skip the movement altogether and work on something else. Like when you got me to sit up and focus on the leg aspect of that Baseworks sequence instead of leaning back. That worked because we entirely took the “lean back / keep neck up” issue out of the equation. I have no idea whether I’ve explained myself any more clearly here or just muddled things further, but I think either way we can move on from this conversation 🙂. I think we are basically saying something similar but just in different ways.

Woah, that was long…sorry. I’m on my computer looking at a big screen.

Also, just in case this isn’t clear - I understand that the idea is that over time through the general body work and awareness shifts that things like neck pain may well get resolved and that I may not have certain issues anymore. Ok, enough said. Time to eat lunch…

---

Key Takeaways from Exchange

1. No miscommunication about empathy: Sara didn’t perceive Patrick as dismissive—the concern was unfounded.

2. Reformer clarification: She wasn’t comparing Baseworks unfavorably to Pilates. She was explaining that some movements simply aren’t accessible for her without an assistive device, regardless of how “basic” they appear. The reformer is a rehab tool that allows gentler iterations of movements.

3. The real insight: Sometimes there’s no modification that works—the movement needs to be skipped entirely and replaced with something else. The example Patrick gave (sitting up and focusing on the leg aspect instead of leaning back) was exactly right because it removed the problematic element altogether.

4. Physio confirmation: Her PT independently identified shallow neck breathing vs. diaphragm/ribcage breathing as a contributor—aligning with the fascia chain discussion from Session 5.

5. She gets the long-term perspective: She understands that the general body work and awareness shifts may resolve these issues over time.

6. Group settings are challenging for her: She knows from experience that group formats tend to result in neck/back issues for her. This is useful context for future sessions.

---

Related

• Communications Guide — Moderation & Intensity
• Session 5 Summary — Working Around Physical Conditions
• Direct Messages

---

To Revisit

Sara’s PT observation about neck breathing vs. diaphragm/ribcage breathing is relevant to our Ignition and Assimilation practices. We haven’t yet added sufficient contextual information and terminology about these practices to the knowledge base. Once that content is developed, revisit this exchange to consider whether there’s a useful connection to share with Sara or to document more broadly for participants working with similar breathing patterns.